Serving Indiana since 1976
American Board of Trial Advocates
The National Trial Lawyers: Top 100
100+ civil jury trials across 18 states
Distracted Driving
Home » Indianapolis Car Accident Lawyer

Car Accident Lawyer in Indianapolis

One of the most common mistakes people make after a car accident is believing that the insurance company for the at-fault driver will act reasonably and in good faith in attempting to resolve their injury claim. Unfortunately, that is usually not the case.

Many of our clients come to us after several months of trying to handle their claim on their own, only to be greatly disappointed in the process and the insurance company’s lowball offer. Attempting to go at it alone first can result in lost evidence and disappearing witnesses, both of which are necessary to maximize the value of your case.

Get the Compensation You Deserve with Our Indiana Automobile Accident Lawyers

In March 2022, the U.S. Department of Transportation’s National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) released a report of motor vehicle crashes that occurred in 2020. According to NHTSA, 38,824 people died on U.S. roads in 2020. This represents a 6.8% increase from the 36,355 fatalities recorded in 2019 and the highest number of fatalities on our roads since 2007.

A financial recovery cannot heal all wounds or restore life to exactly the way it was before a car accident — but it can help you discover and enjoy a hopeful new normal. A financial recovery can ease the expensive burdens caused by overwhelming medical bills, loss of income, and disability. Let our car accident lawyers fight for the compensation you deserve.

Why Choose Us as Your Indianapolis Car Accident Attorneys

Being in a car accident is a frightening and emotionally draining experience, especially if a person sustains major injuries that require significant hospitalization and medical treatment. Families are turned upside down, children are afraid of the changes in their schedules, and medical bills pile up. This is a time when you need experienced and skilled car accident attorneys who are calm, tested, and know how to fight for the maximum payout possible.

Here are some of the key reasons to work with our car accident attorneys in greater Indianapolis:

  • Our attorneys possess decades of legal experience
  • We are not afraid to fight aggressively on your behalf
  • We have a winning track record in personal injury cases
  • Our attorneys offer top-notch client service and communicate openly and frequently with the clients we serve

Attorney Mike Stephenson has 40 years of legal experience and has won many large personal injury claims totaling millions of dollars. He has served as lead trial counsel in more than 100 civil jury trials and has handled litigation in 18 states around the country. State and local polls by peers have listed Mike as one of Indiana’s top lawyers.

The legal team at Stephenson Rife also includes Attorney Brady Rife, who prepares each case as though it may be tried in court. We have achieved outstanding case results and are proud to have many satisfied clients.

At Stephenson Rife, we understand that your family needs to be protected and cared for. If you feel alone and don’t know where to turn, reach out to us. We are here for you. For a free initial consultation, call us at (317) 961-6903.


How Our Shelbyville Car Wreck Attorneys Can Help

There are many ways our car accident lawyers can help clients build a strong car accident claim and secure a significant financial settlement or award. When you work with our vehicle accident attorneys, you can expect the following approaches as part of our process:

  • Sending a letter – As an Indiana car accident attorney, the first thing that we’ll do is send a letter to inform the insurance company that the client is now represented and all communication regarding the accident and the client’s injuries must be directed to us, not the client.
  • Collecting information – Once the client signs a provided medical authorization, we’ll begin collecting medical bills and records from the healthcare providers who provided treatment for the injuries sustained by the client in the crash.
  • Submitting a written demand – This does depend on the severity of the injury and extent of medical treatment necessary to the client, but we may send a written demand to the insurance company for a dollar amount agreed to and authorized by the client prior to filing a lawsuit. If a settlement cannot be reached, or if the case is not appropriate for a pre-suit written demand, a lawsuit will be filed in the county where the crash occurred.
  • Responding to legal requests – Once a lawsuit is filed, a defense lawyer will be hired by the insurance company to defend the lawsuit. The defense lawyer will likely send our office a set of interrogatories (written questions) to be answered by the client, as well as a written request for us to produce various documents such as related medical records and bills. As a Shelbyville car wreck attorney, we assist the client in responding to the interrogatories and gathering the requested documents. Once finalized, we will provide the information to defense counsel.
  • Preparing for and attending depositions – After the written discovery process is completed, the defense counsel will likely want to take the client’s deposition to be conducted either in person or remotely via Zoom. A deposition involves a client being sworn in by a court reporter and asked various questions under oath by the defense attorney, with the court reporter transcribing everything. We thoroughly prepare our clients for this process and are in the room to assert various objections if appropriate.
  • Engaging in mediation – The last major milestone for a client prior to trial is mediation for their case. Mediation is essentially a settlement conference where the parties, their lawyers, and a third-party mediator attempt to come to a resolution of the case for an agreed-upon sum. We thoroughly prepare clients for this process as well as handle the back-and-forth negotiations with a client’s approval.

Every case is different, but no matter what your circumstances are, we will create a legal strategy to help you get the justice you deserve. Our Indiana car crash lawyers prepare every case as if we are going to take it to trial. We ask tough questions that the defense doesn’t want to answer, we find witnesses to support our theory of liability and damages, we find the best experts to support the same, we take thorough depositions, and we push every case toward a trial date.

We put in the time and do the digging that many other firms do not do. If a defense attorney and insurance company do not believe our lawyers will try the case, they will never pay the client the true value of their injuries. 

Who Pays My Attorney Fees?

Here’s the good news: Our car accident attorneys work on contingency, which means we don’t get paid until you get paid. Our fees are paid by the defendant as part of a settlement agreement or jury award. If for some reason your claim is not successful, then you owe us nothing. To learn more about settlements you can visit our settlement FAQ page.

Hit By a Delivery Truck: D.W.’s Car Wreck Story

Our client D.W. had a harrowing experience when he was hit by a delivery truck. He was sitting in the front seat in a vehicle that was smashed into by a UDF delivery truck. It turned out that the UDF driver had multiple driving violations. Attorney Mike Stephenson retained numerous experts to show the jury the devastating effects of our client’s unique injuries.

Before trial, the defendant’s company stated that a jury in a small southern county in Indiana would never return a verdict for $1 million in this case. The defendant was correct; the verdict was twice that amount.

How Much Money Can I Get from My Car Accident?

There are many different kinds of auto accidents, and the amount of damages varies from case to case. It depends on the facts involved and the applicable law. An Indianapolis car accident attorney will tell you that the value of a claim tends to be higher when:

  • Injuries are more severe
  • Long-term disabilities are greater
  • Total bills for treatment and rehabilitation are higher
  • Days and weeks off work are longer

There are some things that could bring down the value of your case, such as evidence that you played a large role in causing the accident or the defendant may have some valid defenses to the claim. Talk to an Indianapolis car accident lawyer at Stephenson Rife to receive a more specific estimate of the value of your case.

Damages You Might Be Entitled To

If you’ve been injured in a car accident in Indiana, you could be entitled to both economic and noneconomic damages, in areas related to:

  • Wrongful death
  • Pain and suffering (current and future)
  • Loss of enjoyment of life
  • Disability
  • Disfigurement or deformity
  • Medical and rehabilitative costs (current and future)
  • Lost wages
  • Loss of future earnings
  • Loss of consortium
  • Property damages

There are numerous factors at play in determining the value of a case including the available insurance coverage for the defendant and the nature and extent of the injuries of the client and how those injuries impact their daily life. As official Shelbyville car wreck lawyers, we work to gather the evidence to maximize the value of each case. Ultimately, the amount of your payout will depend on the severity of your injury and the skill of your car accident attorney in negotiating or litigating your claim.

★ ★ ★ ★ ★
A Client’s Experience

I was in a car accident in March of 2023 while I was pregnant with my son, and it was such a scary time and came with some major medical issues. After fighting with insurance coverage and getting nowhere, I was referred to Stephenson Rife, and it was nothing short of an excellent experience. They listened to me and my concerns and genuinely made me feel like my struggles were theirs. Every time I spoke with either of the paralegals I worked with or my attorney Sean the first question was never directly about the case, it was asking how I was doing, how my family was doing, etc. You can tell they genuinely care about their clients, and with that, they will fight for their clients to get what they deserve! I highly recommend Sean and Stephenson Rife in general if you’re trying to navigate the frustrating world of insurance after a personal injury accident!

— Heather W. Stephenson Rife Client

Will My Life Ever Be the Same Again?

You are probably facing unique challenges and struggles right now. Just as no life is the same as another, no accident is the same. Our car accident lawyer will listen to your story, find out what your life was like before the crash, and learn about your current physical limitations and the medical expenses you’ve incurred. Then we will explain your legal options and help you decide what steps to take next.

For a free initial consultation about your case, call a car accident lawyer at Stephenson Rife at (317) 961-6903. We’re here to help.

Indiana Negligence Laws and Statute of Limitations

Indiana applies the legal theory of modified comparative negligence when determining fault in a car accident case. Also known as the “51% fault” rule, you must be less than 51% at fault for a car crash to file an injury claim. If you are awarded damages for your injuries, the court will reduce your recovery by the percentage of fault that is yours.

For example, if it is determined that you are 30% at fault for a collision and the other party is 70% at fault and the total award is $200,000, then you will receive $140,000 (the total less 30%). The statute of limitations for filing a personal injury claim in Indiana is two years. (Indiana Code Title 34. Civil Law and Procedure § 34-11-2-4).

The clock starts ticking on the date of your car accident injury.

There May Be a Larger Payout Than You Expect

Stephenson Rife brings a lot of experience to the table. That’s why you should never negotiate with an insurance company on your own — instead, let our skilled attorneys do the negotiating for you. A great example is our client Carla Fausnaugh, a mother of three, who was injured in a vehicle accident that was not her fault. The insurance company initially offered her a settlement of only $1,500 more than her medical expenses for her injuries. After she hired Stephenson Rife, we were able to negotiate a settlement for $35,000 — more than 20 times the original offer.

Severity Of Injuries in Car Accidents

Car accident injuries can range from bruises and cuts to severe burns, paralysis and death. The severity of injuries depends on several factors, including:

  • Seat belt use
  • The speed of the vehicles
  • The weight of the vehicles
  • The angle at which a vehicle or object is struck
  • The overall health and age of the person injured

Harm can include soft tissue injuries like strains and whiplash, damage to internal organs, broken bones, spinal cord injuries, and traumatic brain injuries. If the accident causes a fire, there can also be second- and third-degree burns.

Client Testimonial

”My sister and I lost our dad our stepmom are two brothers or uncle and almost our nephew in a car accident and and Stevenson Rife attorneys were amazing. I honestly don’t know what I would have done without them and all their good work and hard work. Thanks to everyone in their office forever grateful.” – Christina Swallows (Google Review)

Service Areas Section

Car Accident Attorneys Serving Central Indiana Communities

Our experienced car accident attorneys are proud to serve families throughout Central Indiana. Click on your city to learn more about our local legal services.

Scroll to Top